Saturday 08/22/2015 by zzyzx

CLIFFORD, SUPER, MAGNABALL, WE'VE SEEN IT ALL!

With a Phish festival and Dick’s in close proximity to each other, many fans had to choose one or the other. I – of course – made my usual call of both, but the trips so close to each other required some sacrifice. Rather than a sane trip, logistics required my flight to be a red-eye into Baltimore-Washington International.

While that sounds like an insane distance, it’s actually closer than most major northeastern cities (and only two hours further than Buffalo) as Baltimore is almost directly due south of Watkins Glen. As I learned driving from Charm City to Buffalo – well Orchard Park, NY – to see the Grateful Dead in 1989, US 15 is a straight shot from Harrisburg, PA to Corning, NY. Back then it was a winding road, pretty, but slowing down for many small towns. Now it’s largely a freeway. The southern section still retains much of its history, having the occasional town slowdown and plenty of “Gentlemen’s Clubs” and tourist traps sitting on the side of the parkway; but by the time you get past the home of the Little League World Series in Williamsport, PA, it’s a freeway. It even branded in part as a disembodied section of the controversial Interstate 99* for 12 miles north of the New York state line.


Photo by Rene Huemer © Phish From the Road

The plan was easy. Land at BWI, drive four hours, crash in my hotel. I didn’t count on the storm. It rolled through The City that Reads right before my plane landed, causing accidents everywhere. It over two full hours to make it to the Pennsylvania state line instead of the expected 45 minutes. It was irritating at first, but it then made sense. Weather fueled traffic jams are a festival tradition. It should be expected to hit one! That wasn’t the only reference to past festivals that happened on this drive. In one of the small towns, I passed a car with the plate “GLO STK,” clearly referencing the Great Went epic war.

Not even Camp Oswego was ignored as there was an exit on US-15 with the name Camp Canoe, bringing back memories of the artist who “rowed” a canoe (actually on wheels) down the main drag of that festival in 1999. Beyond that was the fog covered hills in north-central PA which brought forth memories of the ultimate Phish festival idea: it looked like Gamehendge out there!


Photo © Derek Gregory

The trip to Magnaball was a like a highlight show of the travels to earlier events. And while there might have been a terrifying moment as the storm hit its peak and my window fogged up, leaving me desperately hitting random buttons in the unfamiliar rental car as the ethereal voice of Siri floated through the speakers, telling me that now was the moment to somehow merge onto I-180, without a sense of danger and a bit of terror, the reward would be hardly worth it.

After a visit to Barton Hall to pay homage to 5/8/77 and a few traffic hiccups, Magnaball was achieved. It didn’t run nearly as smoothly as Super Ball IX – perhaps due to the rumored on sale of tickets at the show – but it still was reasonably easy to get there hours early. The first day at a festival is always exciting. There are the art exhibits to explore and – new for 2015 – Phish versions of game shows to play. As I walked by, I found a team looking for a fourth person, so I joined them. When we got to play, our question was, “Name a state that Phish hasn’t played.” As long as you can count on a ton of fans not answering “New York” to be annoying, there is no easier question for a Phish fan who loves geography; we swept the board! (AK, AR, HI, ND, SD, WY, for those keeping track at home).


Photo by Partick Jordan © Phish From the Road

A festival isn’t just about drives and art installations. There are also eight known sets of music. That is the underlying point of this exercise, after all. If there were any questions if the band would need a few minutes to settle into the moment, they were answered almost immediately. “Simple” was never common as a show opener, but Magnaball was its second straight time in that role. It wasn’t a perfunctory version, either; there was a brief jam filled with some beautiful Page riffs. It wouldn’t be the jam of the night by any means, but it felt like a promise.

While “The Dogs” had been played at a few shows since the Haunted House set, it usually was just that the main, high-energy jam would get thrown into the middle of another jam. This was the first complete version with the sampled introduction since the debut, showing that the song can work as a standalone as well as the filling of a jam sandwich.


Trey Anastasio and Eliza Anastasio. Photo by Partick Jordan © Phish From the Road

The first big shock of the night came next. For only the third time since Phish returned in 2009, “The Man Who Stepped into Yesterday” was chosen. It wasn’t just queued; it must have been rehearsed. Trey sometimes has problems with these early compositions, especially the ones that are rarely played, but this was nearly flawless, showing off the beauty of the piece. “Avenu Malkenu” also had a bit extra, as Mike threw a second pass into his “If I Were a Rich Man” jam. Four songs into the festival and we’ve had a doses of energy and beauty, showing that this would not be a throwaway or warm-up set by any means.

After a solid “Free,” Trey took a moment to talk about the Clifford Ball. Back then there was only one child born to the band – Eliza. He remarked that there are now eleven children, but today was Eliza’s 20th birthday. Eliza made a brief appearance on stage, Trey led us into a rendition of “Happy Birthday,” and there was a brief pause. If her quasi-eponymous song would ever get performed again, now would be the time. Instead we got “The Wedge.” Perhaps Eliza doesn’t like that the song pre-dates her by nearly five years, but it could have been worse; she could have been ‘Tela Multibeast Purple Humpback Whale Anastasio’. Regardless, “The Wedge” still resonated with the event. Nineteen years since the first major event: the discovery of the cow funk, the Indian Reservation all night set, the hiatus and the breakup, rehab and recreation, military bases, a desert oasis, and a race track, indeed: we could have come so very far in at least as many years.


"Bathtub Gin" – Photo © Derek Gregory

The surprises weren’t over yet. The first “Mock Song” of 3.0, –in fact only the second “Mock Song” ever – followed. I’m not sure that there was much of a clamor for this one, but this was a better arrangement that the one from The Gorge, with a very cool Page solo and more of a reggae feel. In addition, the line “Fewer, Pink, Kyle, Ball” was changed to “Clifford, Super, Magna Ball” – we’ve known them all, indeed. Keep this up and this will become a real song!

One of the most welcome trends of this era of Phish is what it has done for “Roggae.” The jams in it have been stunning, melodic pieces of soaring beauty. This one was no exception. They’ve gotten very good at peaking as a way of counterpointing the underlying power of the theme. It puts pressure on a song when everyone expects bliss, but they haven’t given us a reason not to yet.


Photo by Rene Huemer © Phish From the Road

After what has already felt like an incredibly strong first set, Phish would be forgiven if they just played a quick peak jam in the closing “Bathtub Gin” and called it a break. That is not what happened by any means. The jam immediately leaves the structure of what the song does and runs off and plays. This “Gin” follows the pattern of many favorite jams in that it does more than one thing at a time. It’s completely improvisational, has multiple parts, but still manages to be danceable. Intense at parts, a complete dance party at others, this jam would have been an obvious highlight of many tours, let alone the first set of a festival. When it finally gets to the peak, tens of thousands of people all engaged in a massive dance party for twenty minutes. It was joyous, the kind of moment that causes us all to go to bizarre places and camp for three days. While not sounding at all similar, the bliss was reminiscent of another famous “Bathtub Gin” at a festival, the 8/17/97 Great Went version. The joy given there will not fade any time soon.

After a long setbreak filled with high-fiving and people glowing over the set, the band came back out into the chilly evening and opened with “Chalk Dust.” There used to be two kinds of “Chalk Dust Torture”: those that had a quick high energy jam followed by the chorus, and the kind – usually played to open a second set – that were open ended and never finished. Recently a third category has emerged. The song has its final chorus sung but rather than draw it to a conclusion a second jam emerges. It might not yet have the legend of the “Mike’s Songsecond jam, but it is always welcome. This one went on for another eleven minutes or so. If you’re looking for a repeat of the soaring energy bliss of the “Gin,” this doesn’t reprise that, but it rather is dark and melodic. The first is great for dancing rapturously in a field at a racetrack; this is more reflective, a good listen on a Sunday morning as you’re fixing your brunch sort of track. Phish play in many styles after all and appeal to many crowds.


"Harry Hood" – Photo © Derek Gregory

The fun of Phish is that you never know what will happen. If I told you that “Ghost,” “Chalk Dust Torture,” and “Bathtub Gin” were all played in succession and two of the three had very interesting jams, no one would expect that it was “Ghost” that just got the quick run through. The jam is more brief than bad. It hits a few quick interesting spaces before resolving into “Rock and Roll.”

The Velvet Underground cover – along with the traditional prayer of “Avenu Malkenu,” the only non-originals of the night – has largely returned to its previous role of being an upbeat rocker to put an exclamation point on the show. Played this early, it promised a bit more. And indeed, it did deliver. Two or three times Trey tried to signal a return to the final chorus, but they wanted to keep going. A slow funk jam gets created. It’s beautiful and you can dance to it and I could have heard Phish play it all night. That’s why I admit to an initial groan while when the “Hood” fired up. Do you mind people? I was enjoying that!


Photo © Jake Silco

Any lingering regret though can’t really survive “Harry Hood.” If for nothing else, at a festival show with an amazing “Bathtub Gin,” it just felt right to also have a massive glowstick war during “Harry Hood.” It’s less nostalgia than an accidental homage. The “Hood” itself was quite interesting. Sacrificing the build jam for a voyage, this jam wanders all over the track. If you’re the kind of person who needs to find something – anything – to complain about with a Phish show, the “Hood” peak was sacrificed in exchange. However, if you’re reaching the point of saying, “Well they ended one cool jam but immediately followed it with another one, but that one didn’t manage to also hit a soaring peak at the very end,” just to find something to point fingers at, well that shows the power of this show.

It wasn’t over yet. After a quick breather with “Waste,” perhaps the most popular of the new songs of this tour, “No Men in No Man’s Land” had one more jam to come. This was more of a fast funky jam than the reflectiveness of the “Chalk Dust” or the “Hood,” but it’s the perfect way to start to wind things down. We’ve done a lot tonight; now let’s dance our way home! Before we do though, there’s one last thing. We’re going to give you a “Slave!”


Photo © Andrea Nusinov

Sets with both a “Hood” and a “Slave” feel somewhat unfair. We’re not going to give you one of your favorite late set songs. Here, have both of them! It might rob the other two nights of possibilities, but it it’s always great when it happens. You don’t mind if I give you one more moment of euphoria, do you?

After the encore, a pretty “Farmhouse” – appropriate for the rural setting – and the always fun “First Tube,” it was time to reflect on a great night. One of the games people like to play when they talk about Phish shows is to break it up into quarters, putting an imaginary break halfway through each set. The reason why that became popular is that there has been a bit of a rut in the past few years, where the third quarter always had the best – the more cynical would say “only good,” but let’s not listen to them, ok? – music of the night. This tour has broken with that with great first sets and jams late into the second. In fact, with the early “TMWSIY,” the great “Gin,” and the late “Hood,” “No Man’s,” and “Slave” combination, it could be argued that all three of the other quadrants managed to surpass the third, not because the third was bad, but because the others were so good. That may or may not be true, but Phish delivered an amazing complete show to open Magnaball. If this turns out to be the warmup night, Magnaball will be the stuff of legend, passed down from generation to generation to while away the long Finger Lakes region winter nights.

* The Interstate highway system has a naming convention. One aspect of it is that north-south roads have odd numbers that increase from west to east. Interstate 99 is not just kind of a weird highway that doesn’t really connect cities – well it’s now two different highways near each other that don’t connect to each other even – but it’s completely misnumbered. Having I-99 being west of I-81 annoys people who care way too much about such issues. I’d mock such people more but back in the early days of Ihoz.com, I was kind of one of them, as http://ihoz.com/I99.html shows.

Phish Summer 2015 – Setlists & Recaps
07/21/15 SetlistRecap – Bend 1
07/22/15 SetlistRecap – Bend 2
07/24/15 SetlistRecap, Recap2 – Shoreline
07/25/15 SetlistRecap – LA Forum
07/28/15 SetlistRecap – Austin
07/29/15 SetlistRecap – Grand Prarie
07/31/15 SetlistRecap – Atlanta 1
08/01/15 SetlistRecap – Atlanta 2
08/02/15 SetlistRecap – Tuscaloosa
08/04/15 SetlistRecap – Nashville
08/05/15 SetlistRecap – Kansas City
08/07/15 SetlistRecap – Blossom
08/08/15 SetlistRecap – Alpine 1
08/09/15 SetlistRecap – Apline 2
08/11/15 SetlistRecap – Mann 1
08/12/15 SetlistRecap – Mann 2
08/14/15 SetlistRecap – Raleigh
08/15/15 SetlistRecap – Merriweather 1
08/16/15 SetlistRecap – Merriweather 2
08/21/15 SetlistRecap – Magnaball 1
08/22/15 SetlistRecap – Magnaball 2
08/23/15 SetlistRecap – Magnaball 3
09/04/15 SetlistRecap – Dick's 1
09/05/15 SetlistRecap – Dick's 2
09/06/15 SetlistRecap – Dick's 3


Limited Edition MagnaBall Poster by Jim Pollock

If you liked this blog post, one way you could "like" it is to make a donation to The Mockingbird Foundation, the sponsor of Phish.net. Support music education for children, and you just might change the world.


Comments

, comment by illbuyyouaewe
illbuyyouaewe This is an altogether excellent review. The review is fair, accurate, and it made me even more excited to relisten to the show. Great work.
, comment by RunawayJeff
RunawayJeff Not only a great first night, but an excellent and well thought out review from David here! It even had some Interstate nerdiness to remind me of the old days of reading House of ZZYZX and wondering why someone cared so much about Interstates!
, comment by nichobert
nichobert Couching on the audio stream last night.. It was pretty humorous seeing the amount of bile thrown Farmhouse's way. And then Phish promptly deciding to make it a special version with Page taking the solo away from Trey and then exploring the kind of super delicate beautiful space they also did in the Alpine 2012 version.

Did anyone feel the need to comment? Of course not.
, comment by FACTSAREUSELESS
FACTSAREUSELESS Good review. I heard things much the way you did, though I think you were a little more generous with praise than I would have been. It was a great show. I think the boys definitely gave it an all-star effort. There were some unique and fine moments, a few good transitions and some nice cohesion, but there were also some not-so-good transitions, some incredibly botched playing and a couple of cover-your-eyes-awful moments. So, a typical night of Phish, you would say.

Overall I continue, as most of us, to be completely stoked about the state of the band and how they are playing generally. I was a little hopeful that they would be somewhat tighter by now, but they've been extremely inventive and playful and are playing with so much fire that it makes up for it. I think they are certainly more cohesive than last year. Trey has gotten more sloppy as the tour has progressed, which doesn't thrill me, but it is what it is.

The Rift was horrendous. Trey just couldn't play it at all. The Gin was so badly botched by Fishman I thought they'd restart the song. Really, I did, but then of course the jam started and all was forgotten a few minutes out of the song proper. Roggae was the same, with the timing completely off and Trey forgetting how to play the beginning riffs. Mike and Page kept chugging along until he got it, then, again, the peak of the song makes you forget the mistakes. It turned out to be a beautiful version in the end.

In the second set, I thought Ghost was a bad call coming out of that beautiful Chalk Dust. Really loved the space they found in the CDT and Ghost was not needed there. Nor did it go anywhere interesting.

But that would be the end of my negative criticisms, for sure. The rest was so enormously fantastic that it still ranked as a great show.

Loved TMWSTIY> Avenu Malkenu, which was really sweet. Of course I loved the Gin. It just wouldn't quit. As I said already, this Chalk Dust was really special. Love the space they found there. R&R was well-played and it was nice to see it get prominent 2nd set placement again. It's been missed.

As much as I thought Ghost was the wrong call, Waste PERFECT call, and beautifully delivered. Just the perfect cool-down there in that spot, and the Hood was epic. I loved the left turns this Hood takes, not once, but multiple times. Wasn't sure they would finish the song at one juncture. A couple of years ago, this Hood would've stolen the evening, but that's where we are now with these guys. The standard is HIGH.

No Man was an orgasmic type 1 peak, and then to close with Slave (and a great Slave it was), was pure gravy, as the reviewer correctly pointed out. And a LONG set it was. They could have ended with Hood> Cavern (which is what I expected actually), but to have an additional 24 minutes of high quality music after that Hood is extraordinary.

As @zzyzx correctly points out, if this is a warm up, then this may go down as the best festival of all time. What a tour. Best since '97.
, comment by forbin1
forbin1 Great writeup...I haven't had a chance to listen to this show yet...thanks for the review...it was a pleasure reading...
, comment by raidcehlalred
raidcehlalred Interesting review. A lot of people will talk about the Gin and the Hood. Feel good about that Hood. If Fish was displeased about that Gin, he exorcised his anger around eight minutes in. Hope people don't take this the wrong way. It's a awesome time to be following the band. But I'll take an even lesser discussed Gin like 7/8/98 over the MB version. The playing deviates more from 'other' jams, and, thus, is more interesting. Perhaps the reflects some of what @FACTSAREUSELESS mentioned; then again, this might not be the case (I do think the band is tight 'in' their jamming).

However, take ten minutes inside the playing here, insert it following some Thursday night Disease, and it's sorta the same. Of course this isn't a bad thing. Like we saw with Nevada and Tweezer, there is a prisoner of the moment effect at work. The Dust - despite its strange start - gets really great. I like what @nichobert has had to say about Farmhouse, so I'll leave that to him. TMWSIY is always welcome, but quite a strange spot. Jersey a few years back was odd; this: odder. Leave it to the band.
, comment by FACTSAREUSELESS
FACTSAREUSELESS @raidcehlalred said:
Interesting review. A lot of people will talk about the Gin and the Hood. Feel good about that Hood. If Fish was displeased about that Gin, he exorcised his anger around eight minutes in. Hope people don't take this the wrong way. It's a awesome time to be following the band. But I'll take an even lesser discussed Gin like 7/8/98 over the MB version. The playing deviates more from 'other' jams, and, thus, is more interesting. Perhaps the reflects some of what @FACTSAREUSELESS mentioned; then again, this might not be the case (I do think the band is tight 'in' their jamming).

However, take ten minutes inside the playing here, insert it following some Thursday night Disease, and it's sorta the same. Of course this isn't a bad thing. Like we saw with Nevada and Tweezer, there is a prisoner of the moment effect at work. The Dust - despite its strange start - gets really great. I like what @nichobert has had to say about Farmhouse, so I'll leave that to him. TMWSIY is always welcome, but quite a strange spot. Jersey a few years back was odd; this: odder. Leave it to the band.
They seem to be willing to noodle a bit where before the ripcord would rule the day. I think this may be what you are hearing in terms of "sameness". One of the things I love about Trey is his vision. He is usually a couple steps ahead of most musicians in his thinking. Not reactionary but proactive. And he's very thematic. So I think there are certain musical mechanisms which get employed frequently by the band which signal direction. These mechanisms result in similarities as they explore space.

The other thing to remember is that we're dealing with sound, but in a finite spectrum. There are only so many chords, only so many octaves. The rest is is all manipulation of space in terms of rhythm, pace, whole/half/quarter notes, rests, etc. Major key, minor key, dissonance. Unless they changed instruments all their music sounds pretty much the same to anyone not familiar with the nuance of their style. So it's sort of a dead end argument.

The Gin became great in my view because it didn't quit. The early part of the jam was interesting but, because they didn't give up on it and they let it find legs, it got better and better until it was epic. That's one of things with these jams. They've had some short jams this tour which I think have been superior to anything they've done on the longer, more heralded pieces, but part of the experience as a listener is the journey, so length becomes a factor in enjoyment. It's part of the mystery of exploration.
, comment by raidcehlalred
raidcehlalred @FACTSAREUSELESS said:
@raidcehlalred said:
Interesting review. A lot of people will talk about the Gin and the Hood. Feel good about that Hood. If Fish was displeased about that Gin, he exorcised his anger around eight minutes in. Hope people don't take this the wrong way. It's a awesome time to be following the band. But I'll take an even lesser discussed Gin like 7/8/98 over the MB version. The playing deviates more from 'other' jams, and, thus, is more interesting. Perhaps the reflects some of what @FACTSAREUSELESS mentioned; then again, this might not be the case (I do think the band is tight 'in' their jamming).

However, take ten minutes inside the playing here, insert it following some Thursday night Disease, and it's sorta the same. Of course this isn't a bad thing. Like we saw with Nevada and Tweezer, there is a prisoner of the moment effect at work. The Dust - despite its strange start - gets really great. I like what @nichobert has had to say about Farmhouse, so I'll leave that to him. TMWSIY is always welcome, but quite a strange spot. Jersey a few years back was odd; this: odder. Leave it to the band.
They seem to be willing to noodle a bit where before the ripcord would rule the day. I think this may be what you are hearing in terms of "sameness". One of the things I love about Trey is his vision. He is usually a couple steps ahead of most musicians in his thinking. Not reactionary but proactive. And he's very thematic. So I think there are certain musical mechanisms which get employed frequently by the band which signal direction. These mechanisms result in similarities as they explore space.

The other thing to remember is that we're dealing with sound, but in a finite spectrum. There are only so many chords, only so many octaves. The rest is is all manipulation of space in terms of rhythm, pace, whole/half/quarter notes, rests, etc. Major key, minor key, dissonance. Unless they changed instruments all their music sounds pretty much the same to anyone not familiar with the nuance of their style. So it's sort of a dead end argument.

The Gin became great in my view because it didn't quit. The early part of the jam was interesting but, because they didn't give up on it and they let it find legs, it got better and better until it was epic. That's one of things with these jams. They've had some short jams this tour which I think have been superior to anything they've done on the longer, more heralded pieces, but part of the experience as a listener is the journey, so length becomes a factor in enjoyment. It's part of the mystery of exploration.
Totally get what you are saying. I'm sort of considering the manipulation of space you discuss so well. In many ways, the 'quiet' part of this jam reminded me of the IT Dust. The nuance of that style was so much more abrasive and interesting and simply Different from what I had heard before that I was blown away. What emerged from this quiet space was what I hear as sameness. It's cool sameness, don't get me wrong. It's really cool - and in the moment it's: more, more, more, more. But for me it's a model of this era, not altogether different from last year's (I think first set) NYC Gin.

People - invariably - talk about the Went Gin. I understand why anyone would want to be a part of something like that; it doesn't get much better. But this wasn't that. This was, as you succinctly state, a musical sort of passage, with Trey thinking though ideas (here it might be nice for Mike not to be quite so thunderous - or to modulate/shift pitches).

Not sure what you mean, exactly, by dead end argument.

Even some Waste-style playing - extended - would sound cool. Like you I thought it was great - and Trey's run always reminds me of the Went Gin.

Cohesion, and not noodling in that space, I guess is what I'm saying. Or Trey erupting and modulating with more notes. But it was really cool. Some interesting syncopation, too.
, comment by raidcehlalred
raidcehlalred @FACTSAREUSELESS said:
@raidcehlalred said:
Interesting review. A lot of people will talk about the Gin and the Hood. Feel good about that Hood. If Fish was displeased about that Gin, he exorcised his anger around eight minutes in. Hope people don't take this the wrong way. It's a awesome time to be following the band. But I'll take an even lesser discussed Gin like 7/8/98 over the MB version. The playing deviates more from 'other' jams, and, thus, is more interesting. Perhaps the reflects some of what @FACTSAREUSELESS mentioned; then again, this might not be the case (I do think the band is tight 'in' their jamming).

However, take ten minutes inside the playing here, insert it following some Thursday night Disease, and it's sorta the same. Of course this isn't a bad thing. Like we saw with Nevada and Tweezer, there is a prisoner of the moment effect at work. The Dust - despite its strange start - gets really great. I like what @nichobert has had to say about Farmhouse, so I'll leave that to him. TMWSIY is always welcome, but quite a strange spot. Jersey a few years back was odd; this: odder. Leave it to the band.
They seem to be willing to noodle a bit where before the ripcord would rule the day. I think this may be what you are hearing in terms of "sameness". One of the things I love about Trey is his vision. He is usually a couple steps ahead of most musicians in his thinking. Not reactionary but proactive. And he's very thematic. So I think there are certain musical mechanisms which get employed frequently by the band which signal direction. These mechanisms result in similarities as they explore space.

The other thing to remember is that we're dealing with sound, but in a finite spectrum. There are only so many chords, only so many octaves. The rest is is all manipulation of space in terms of rhythm, pace, whole/half/quarter notes, rests, etc. Major key, minor key, dissonance. Unless they changed instruments all their music sounds pretty much the same to anyone not familiar with the nuance of their style. So it's sort of a dead end argument.

The Gin became great in my view because it didn't quit. The early part of the jam was interesting but, because they didn't give up on it and they let it find legs, it got better and better until it was epic. That's one of things with these jams. They've had some short jams this tour which I think have been superior to anything they've done on the longer, more heralded pieces, but part of the experience as a listener is the journey, so length becomes a factor in enjoyment. It's part of the mystery of exploration.
i should add that while in never felt this way in 94 or 95 (i was just a kid, but it still holds, i think) i did feel this way come fall 97 and 98 - to the extent that i almost/did pass up some great shows because of 'funk' malaise. the playing became redundant. summer 97 was wild - but fall became interestingly / (less)interestingly predictable. it'd take a rochester or a vegas (three) to wake me up.

98 saw the band toying with a bunch of covers to 'liven' things up. i WANT to think they're doing that with set list construction here; but what do i know.

i do know that i love this year of phish (and the best succession of new tunes since 97, too).

as, seemingly, do all. fun times.
, comment by FACTSAREUSELESS
FACTSAREUSELESS @raidcehlalred said:
@FACTSAREUSELESS said:
@raidcehlalred said:
Interesting review. A lot of people will talk about the Gin and the Hood. Feel good about that Hood. If Fish was displeased about that Gin, he exorcised his anger around eight minutes in. Hope people don't take this the wrong way. It's a awesome time to be following the band. But I'll take an even lesser discussed Gin like 7/8/98 over the MB version. The playing deviates more from 'other' jams, and, thus, is more interesting. Perhaps the reflects some of what @FACTSAREUSELESS mentioned; then again, this might not be the case (I do think the band is tight 'in' their jamming).

However, take ten minutes inside the playing here, insert it following some Thursday night Disease, and it's sorta the same. Of course this isn't a bad thing. Like we saw with Nevada and Tweezer, there is a prisoner of the moment effect at work. The Dust - despite its strange start - gets really great. I like what @nichobert has had to say about Farmhouse, so I'll leave that to him. TMWSIY is always welcome, but quite a strange spot. Jersey a few years back was odd; this: odder. Leave it to the band.
They seem to be willing to noodle a bit where before the ripcord would rule the day. I think this may be what you are hearing in terms of "sameness". One of the things I love about Trey is his vision. He is usually a couple steps ahead of most musicians in his thinking. Not reactionary but proactive. And he's very thematic. So I think there are certain musical mechanisms which get employed frequently by the band which signal direction. These mechanisms result in similarities as they explore space.

The other thing to remember is that we're dealing with sound, but in a finite spectrum. There are only so many chords, only so many octaves. The rest is is all manipulation of space in terms of rhythm, pace, whole/half/quarter notes, rests, etc. Major key, minor key, dissonance. Unless they changed instruments all their music sounds pretty much the same to anyone not familiar with the nuance of their style. So it's sort of a dead end argument.

The Gin became great in my view because it didn't quit. The early part of the jam was interesting but, because they didn't give up on it and they let it find legs, it got better and better until it was epic. That's one of things with these jams. They've had some short jams this tour which I think have been superior to anything they've done on the longer, more heralded pieces, but part of the experience as a listener is the journey, so length becomes a factor in enjoyment. It's part of the mystery of exploration.
Totally get what you are saying. I'm sort of considering the manipulation of space you discuss so well. In many ways, the 'quiet' part of this jam reminded me of the IT Dust. The nuance of that style was so much more abrasive and interesting and simply Different from what I had heard before that I was blown away. What emerged from this quiet space was what I hear as sameness. It's cool sameness, don't get me wrong. It's really cool - and in the moment it's: more, more, more, more. But for me it's a model of this era, not altogether different from last year's (I think first set) NYC Gin.

People - invariably - talk about the Went Gin. I understand why anyone would want to be a part of something like that; it doesn't get much better. But this wasn't that. This was, as you succinctly state, a musical sort of passage, with Trey thinking though ideas (here it might be nice for Mike not to be quite so thunderous - or to modulate/shift pitches).

Not sure what you mean, exactly, by dead end argument.

Even some Waste-style playing - extended - would sound cool. Like you I thought it was great - and Trey's run always reminds me of the Went Gin.

Cohesion, and not noodling in that space, I guess is what I'm saying. Or Trey erupting and modulating with more notes. But it was really cool. Some interesting syncopation, too.
Yes, exactly. We're more or less on the same page, I think.

Not sure what I mean by "dead-end argument" either. I think I just ran out of words.
, comment by FACTSAREUSELESS
FACTSAREUSELESS @raidcehlalred said:
@FACTSAREUSELESS said:
@raidcehlalred said:
Interesting review. A lot of people will talk about the Gin and the Hood. Feel good about that Hood. If Fish was displeased about that Gin, he exorcised his anger around eight minutes in. Hope people don't take this the wrong way. It's a awesome time to be following the band. But I'll take an even lesser discussed Gin like 7/8/98 over the MB version. The playing deviates more from 'other' jams, and, thus, is more interesting. Perhaps the reflects some of what @FACTSAREUSELESS mentioned; then again, this might not be the case (I do think the band is tight 'in' their jamming).

However, take ten minutes inside the playing here, insert it following some Thursday night Disease, and it's sorta the same. Of course this isn't a bad thing. Like we saw with Nevada and Tweezer, there is a prisoner of the moment effect at work. The Dust - despite its strange start - gets really great. I like what @nichobert has had to say about Farmhouse, so I'll leave that to him. TMWSIY is always welcome, but quite a strange spot. Jersey a few years back was odd; this: odder. Leave it to the band.
They seem to be willing to noodle a bit where before the ripcord would rule the day. I think this may be what you are hearing in terms of "sameness". One of the things I love about Trey is his vision. He is usually a couple steps ahead of most musicians in his thinking. Not reactionary but proactive. And he's very thematic. So I think there are certain musical mechanisms which get employed frequently by the band which signal direction. These mechanisms result in similarities as they explore space.

The other thing to remember is that we're dealing with sound, but in a finite spectrum. There are only so many chords, only so many octaves. The rest is is all manipulation of space in terms of rhythm, pace, whole/half/quarter notes, rests, etc. Major key, minor key, dissonance. Unless they changed instruments all their music sounds pretty much the same to anyone not familiar with the nuance of their style. So it's sort of a dead end argument.

The Gin became great in my view because it didn't quit. The early part of the jam was interesting but, because they didn't give up on it and they let it find legs, it got better and better until it was epic. That's one of things with these jams. They've had some short jams this tour which I think have been superior to anything they've done on the longer, more heralded pieces, but part of the experience as a listener is the journey, so length becomes a factor in enjoyment. It's part of the mystery of exploration.
i should add that while in never felt this way in 94 or 95 (i was just a kid, but it still holds, i think) i did feel this way come fall 97 and 98 - to the extent that i almost/did pass up some great shows because of 'funk' malaise. the playing became redundant. summer 97 was wild - but fall became interestingly / (less)interestingly predictable. it'd take a rochester or a vegas (three) to wake me up.

98 saw the band toying with a bunch of covers to 'liven' things up. i WANT to think they're doing that with set list construction here; but what do i know.

i do know that i love this year of phish (and the best succession of new tunes since 97, too).

as, seemingly, do all. fun times.
Yes, I agree. The cow-funk thing had a certain reduncancy to it that most fans, if they were honest, would admit. The fans and band alike could sense that the magic moment which was '97 was quickly slipping from everyone's grasp, but noone wanted to acknowledge it.

The underwhelmingness of '98 is testimony to it however. While there were many great moments in '98 (see Prague), the year in general never generated the same level of excitement as '97 did. It couldn't. What goes up must come down. And as soon as you try to label and package something that begins organically ("cow-funk" ;) you immediately lose it.

All I know is that the Fall of '13 they had IT, and last year, with the notable exception of 3-4 shows, they didn't. Now they have IT again.

If the boys in the band could find a way to bottle IT never lose it again, they would collectively give up all their material possessions to do so, but they can't. They are chasing it just as we are. And they're just as excited as us when they find it. It's pure joy.

I agree with your comment about the noodling, but I think rather than noodle they are just playing "without a net". The interpersonal aspect of the band itself is in safe place and they are okay with taking chances which were not safe to take in '09 or '10. This has been a progressive development we've seen happen before our eyes/ears. Enjoy it while it lasts. These things can't be controlled.

Next year we may be talking and debating about why it seems Trey "has lost interest" or "isn't focused". It's how these things go.
, comment by The_Marsist
The_Marsist I'm on the campground at Magnaball right now. This morning, my friends and I were awakened to the sound of the guy camped next to us moaning in his sleep. The moans kept alternating between pleasurable sounding and pained, all the while growing in intensity. Right when the moaning reached its apex he yelled out "BATHTUB GIN!!!"

Yeah...that was a damn fine jam.
, comment by raidcehlalred
raidcehlalred @FACTSAREUSELESS said:
@raidcehlalred said:
@FACTSAREUSELESS said:
@raidcehlalred said:
Interesting review. A lot of people will talk about the Gin and the Hood. Feel good about that Hood. If Fish was displeased about that Gin, he exorcised his anger around eight minutes in. Hope people don't take this the wrong way. It's a awesome time to be following the band. But I'll take an even lesser discussed Gin like 7/8/98 over the MB version. The playing deviates more from 'other' jams, and, thus, is more interesting. Perhaps the reflects some of what @FACTSAREUSELESS mentioned; then again, this might not be the case (I do think the band is tight 'in' their jamming).

However, take ten minutes inside the playing here, insert it following some Thursday night Disease, and it's sorta the same. Of course this isn't a bad thing. Like we saw with Nevada and Tweezer, there is a prisoner of the moment effect at work. The Dust - despite its strange start - gets really great. I like what @nichobert has had to say about Farmhouse, so I'll leave that to him. TMWSIY is always welcome, but quite a strange spot. Jersey a few years back was odd; this: odder. Leave it to the band.
They seem to be willing to noodle a bit where before the ripcord would rule the day. I think this may be what you are hearing in terms of "sameness". One of the things I love about Trey is his vision. He is usually a couple steps ahead of most musicians in his thinking. Not reactionary but proactive. And he's very thematic. So I think there are certain musical mechanisms which get employed frequently by the band which signal direction. These mechanisms result in similarities as they explore space.

The other thing to remember is that we're dealing with sound, but in a finite spectrum. There are only so many chords, only so many octaves. The rest is is all manipulation of space in terms of rhythm, pace, whole/half/quarter notes, rests, etc. Major key, minor key, dissonance. Unless they changed instruments all their music sounds pretty much the same to anyone not familiar with the nuance of their style. So it's sort of a dead end argument.

The Gin became great in my view because it didn't quit. The early part of the jam was interesting but, because they didn't give up on it and they let it find legs, it got better and better until it was epic. That's one of things with these jams. They've had some short jams this tour which I think have been superior to anything they've done on the longer, more heralded pieces, but part of the experience as a listener is the journey, so length becomes a factor in enjoyment. It's part of the mystery of exploration.
i should add that while in never felt this way in 94 or 95 (i was just a kid, but it still holds, i think) i did feel this way come fall 97 and 98 - to the extent that i almost/did pass up some great shows because of 'funk' malaise. the playing became redundant. summer 97 was wild - but fall became interestingly / (less)interestingly predictable. it'd take a rochester or a vegas (three) to wake me up.

98 saw the band toying with a bunch of covers to 'liven' things up. i WANT to think they're doing that with set list construction here; but what do i know.

i do know that i love this year of phish (and the best succession of new tunes since 97, too).

as, seemingly, do all. fun times.
Yes, I agree. The cow-funk thing had a certain reduncancy to it that most fans, if they were honest, would admit. The fans and band alike could sense that the magic moment which was '97 was quickly slipping from everyone's grasp, but noone wanted to acknowledge it.

The underwhelmingness of '98 is testimony to it however. While there were many great moments in '98 (see Prague), the year in general never generated the same level of excitement as '97 did. It couldn't. What goes up must come down. And as soon as you try to label and package something that begins organically ("cow-funk" ;) you immediately lose it.

All I know is that the Fall of '13 they had IT, and last year, with the notable exception of 3-4 shows, they didn't. Now they have IT again.

If the boys in the band could find a way to bottle IT never lose it again, they would collectively give up all their material possessions to do so, but they can't. They are chasing it just as we are. And they're just as excited as us when they find it. It's pure joy.

I agree with your comment about the noodling, but I think rather than noodle they are just playing "without a net". The interpersonal aspect of the band itself is in safe place and they are okay with taking chances which were not safe to take in '09 or '10. This has been a progressive development we've seen happen before our eyes/ears. Enjoy it while it lasts. These things can't be controlled.

Next year we may be talking and debating about why it seems Trey "has lost interest" or "isn't focused". It's how these things go.
We are.

The point about playing sans net is a good one. And you are correct in that, like everything, I need to step back and appreciate what's happening.

Truly, I do.

It helps me to work out my ideas in writing. You, and a few others here, help these thoughts crystallize.

What I try to express to friends of mine who don't like the band (or, more accurately, don't understand them), is the joy aspect you mention. Right now, for instance, I'm taking a breather and contrasting the Blossom Dust and the Gin we've been discussing. Both are exuberant. There is that passage in the Dust, say 11:40ish, that simply becomes joyous.

You, or another, noted how it's similar to the Wedge from last year.

And then someone else noted how it's similar to the Sugarbush 94 Reba.

I write about Disease and such frequently. I get why they play Dust so often (and where): it works. I wonder if they are chasing something with Disease....
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Support Phish.net & Mbird
Fun with Setlists
Check our Phish setlists and sideshow setlists!
Phish News
Subscribe to Phish-News for exclusive info while on tour!


Phish.net

Phish.net is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal | DMCA

© 1990-2024  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc. | Hosted by Linode